BOOKMARK AND SHARE
This article was originally published at the Fidessa blog, and is reproduced here with permission.
By Steve Grob
I was hoping to enjoy the last few weeks of summer in relative peace, but it seems that another regulatory storm is brewing. This time it’s over the unbundling of research and it all stems from ESMA’s interpretation that, under MiFID II, research is an “inducement to trade” and therefore cannot be paid for out of commissions. This threatens to completely derail the economics of trading and reduce the quantity and quality of research available (and the resultant investment decisions). The current approach allows for research and other legitimate broker services to be paid for out of dealing commission and is managed and controlled via commission sharing arrangements (CSAs). Provided the right systems are in place the buy-side can evidence all of their decisions as to where commission dollars were spent and the sell-side can be adequately rewarded for providing quality research – the better the research it provides, the more commission dollars it attracts.
I wonder if a better approach, then, might be to ensure the whole CSA process is standardised and works properly, since everyone seems happy with it. Otherwise, we will face the worst possible outcome. Firms will have little incentive to invest in proper CSA management systems today if they believe that everything will eventually be fully unbundled. This will do little for industry efficiency and seems to fly squarely in the face of any regulatory objective of transparency. And, at the same time, the whole of the European investment industry will be placed at a competitive disadvantage as the unbundled ’sticker price’ of their services will appear much higher than that of their competitors in the US or Asia.
News: Horizon Software first to offer options trading system in China
7 July 2014 – Horizon Software
7 July 2014, Paris, Shanghai: Horizon Software, innovative provider of front-end trading solutions, is the first vendor to offer an options trading system in China’…
News: GBST’s FTT solution goes live at global investment bank
22 July 2014 – GBST
Delivering French and Italian Financial Transaction Tax compliance London, United Kingdom, 22 July, 2014 – GBST (ASX: GBT), the ASX-listed wealth management and …
Event: Mifid II for Brokers
Starting on: Tuesday 9th of September, 2014. Posted by: HFT Review.
There is no let-up for brokers in the pace of regulatory change and with Emir implementation in full sway, thoughts are turning to Mifid II. This event will bring together some key figures from the European broking community to discuss the challenges and opportunities within Mifid II and share ideas on the latest thinking on Esma’s technical standards and identify the key areas of concern.
News: BOAT clients move to Cinnober
12 August 2014 – Cinnober
In what is seen as a major endorsement for Cinnober’s new management of BOAT, the company announces today that all BOAT customers have now confirmed their future co…
News: Traiana launches enhanced cross-asset matching engine
14 August 2014 – Traiana
Post-trade Securities network volume surges by over 1000% in past 12 months London, 13 August 2014 – Traiana, the leading provider of pre-trade risk and post-trade pr…
News: KVH Expands Its Financial Services Product Suite With Addition Of MarketPrizm
24 June 2014 – KVH
Partnering with MarketPrizm to strengthen KVH’s market position in AsiaKVH Co. Ltd., Asia’s leading information delivery platform headquartered in Tokyo, Japan, to…