This article was originally published at the Fidessa Regulation Matters blog, and is reproduced here with the author’s permission.
By Ana Herrero-Wallace
I find it rather appropriate this season that the three European bodies – the Commission, the Council and the Parliament (the latter with rapporteur Arlene McCarthy’s version) – are each bearing us a gift. Instead of the traditional gold, frankincense and myrrh, each is bringing its own take on the Market Abuse Directive. These slightly different texts will be discussed during the trilogue which should start in Brussels any day now.
One important element in all three documents is the repeated mention of the widening of scope to include benchmarks and interest rates in light of the recent Libor rate rigging cases against several big banks. They all make it clear that there will be deterrent sanctions and that market manipulation or insider dealing will be treated as a criminal offence. Unlike civil offences, the perpetrator can face a prison sentence in addition to being subject to a financial penalty. The Parliament’s McCarthy text calls for greater spending and investment by Member States to ensure that effective investigative tools are available.
The Parliament prescribes imprisonment for those convicted of market abuse; a term of at least five years for insider dealing and at least two years for improper disclosure of inside information and the dissemination of information through the media or other means. The proportionality of any financial sanction will depend on the profits made and the extent of the damage done.
The Council document provides the most descriptive definition of how the directive should apply to all financial instruments, regardless of the trading platform, and includes OTC trading in its scope.
So the final directive will be an amalgamation of the three different offerings. We can only hope that the mixing of these various ingredients doesn’t resemble an ancient alchemist’s disastrous experiment and that the gift turns out to be real and not fool’s gold.
The opinions and writing contained in this article are of the author alone and do not necessarily represent those of HFTReview.com.
News: Traders May Face Nordic-Style EU Fees for Canceled Orders [Bloomberg]
25 March 2012 – High Frequency Trading Review
By Jim Brunsden High-frequency traders and other investors may face punitive fees when they create market volatility by placing excessive numbers of canceled orders under E…
News: SEC, U.S. Attorney And FBI Announce 13 Charged In Connection With Securities Kickback Schemes – SEC Suspends Trading In Seven Companies
1 December 2011 – News Articles
The Securities and Exchange Commission, U.S. Attorney for the District of Massachusetts, and Federal Bureau of Investigation today announced parallel cases filed in federal co…
News: José Manuel Durão Barroso President Of The European Commission – Joint European Parliament Debate On The Forthcoming European Council Meeting And The Multiannual Financial Framework – nEuropean Parliament /Strasbourg 13 June 2012
13 June 2012 – News Articles
Mr President, Minister, Honourable members. You have invited me to prepare with you the next European Council, and to discuss the economic situation and the multiannual financ…
News: José Manuel Durão Barroso President Of The European Commission The State Of Europe – Die Europa Rede Berlin, 9 November 2011 Haus Der Berliner Festspiele
10 November 2011 – News Articles
Sehr geehrter Herr Bundestagspräsident Lammert, Sehr geehrter Herr Vorsitzender, lieber Hans-Gert Pöttering, Sehr geehrter Herr Vorsitzender Berg, Sehr geehrter Herr…
News: EU Lawmakers OK Transactions Tax; National Vetoes Remain [Wall Street Journal]
25 May 2012 – High Frequency Trading Review
By Laurence Norman BRUSSELS (Dow Jones)–The European Parliament voted for a European Union-wide financial transactions tax Wednesday, a measure many member states, with a …
News: FIA EPTA broadly welcomes proposed German HFT legislation
15 January 2013 – HFT Review
BRUSSELS (15 January 2013) – FIA European Principal Traders Association said it supports the overall direction and objectives of Germany’s proposed regulation o…
News: IPC is First to Deploy TradeView from Datacom Systems
16 January 2013 – Datacom Systems Inc
IPC IS FIRST TO DEPLOY TRADEVIEW, THE REVOLUTIONARY BREAKTHROUGH IN THE REAL TIME MONITORING OF MARKET DATA FEEDS FROM DATACOM SYSTEMS IPC will also deploy network ta…